In short: Yes. A person aggrieved by the competent authority's order can approach the Bombay High Court in its writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India. The Court's role is narrow: it does not rehear the matter as an appeal would.
What the order is
On an application under section 11(3) of MOFA, the competent authority verifies the documents, makes such enquiry as it considers necessary, and hears the promoter. If it finds the case fit, it issues a certificate under section 11(4) that the society is entitled to a unilateral deemed conveyance. The certificate goes to the Sub-Registrar, who registers the instrument under section 11(5) after issuing a summons to the promoter and hearing the parties.
There are therefore two stages at which a builder or landowner is heard: before the competent authority, and before the Sub-Registrar.
Who may want to challenge it
- The builder or promoter, usually on the area conveyed, on unused development rights claimed to be retained, or on the ground of not being heard.
- The landowner, where the builder held only development rights and the owner disputes what passes to the society.
- A neighbouring society on the same layout, where the land allotted to one society affects the entitlement of another.
- The society itself, where the application is rejected or allowed for a smaller area than claimed.
The Government Resolution of 22 June 2018 directs the competent authority to check that the holders shown on the 7/12 extract or property card, and all other societies, companies and apartment associations on the same layout, are made parties, and to issue a hearing notice to all of them under rule 13(2) of the MOFA Rules, 1964. A person who should have been made a party and was not heard may raise that in a challenge.
The route: writ petition
The competent authority acts under a statute and must follow fair procedure. Its order can be questioned in a writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India before the Bombay High Court.
A writ court does not rehear the matter as an appeal would. The Supreme Court has said that section 11 proceedings are summary, that the competent authority must record reasons, and that a writ court should generally interfere with a deemed conveyance order only if it is manifestly illegal (Arunkumar H. Shah HUF v. Avon Arcade Premises Co-operative Society Ltd., 2025 INSC 524). A denial of a fair hearing, an error of jurisdiction, or an order unsupported by reasons or the record may support a challenge, depending on the facts. A dispute over title or over the extent of land claimed does not by itself make the order unlawful, because those rights can be decided in a civil suit (same judgment).
Disputes about title
The enquiry under section 11 is a summary one, on documents. The competent authority must verify the documents and hear the parties, but it cannot finally decide title as a civil court would. An aggrieved party can still file a civil suit to establish its rights after a deemed conveyance order (same judgment).
Is there a time limit?
MOFA fixes the time within which the competent authority should decide, which is a reasonable time and in any case not later than six months under section 11(4). That is the deadline for the authority's decision, not a filing deadline for a writ petition. No fixed limitation period applies to a writ petition under Article 226, but the High Court may refuse relief for unexplained delay, so a party should approach the Court promptly and explain any delay.
What a challenge does not do automatically
Filing a petition does not by itself stop the next steps. The Supreme Court has noted that a registering officer can refuse registration only on limited grounds, one of which is a competent court's prohibitory order in force (Arunkumar H. Shah HUF). A party who wants the order stayed has to ask the court for it.
For a society defending its order
- Keep the complete record of what was filed before the competent authority, with proof of service of notices on the builder and landowner.
- Complete stamping, registration and mutation without delay once the certificate is issued.
- Check the area and the FSI figures in the order against the architect's certificate before registration, so that any error is corrected early.
For a society whose application was rejected
A rejection is usually on a specific defect: missing agreements, an unclear area, or a dispute between societies on a shared layout.
Whether the society can file a fresh application depends on the rejection order and the defect. A fresh application to correct a curable filing defect may be possible if the order permits it and does not finally decide the same issue. A society should not assume that "liberty to apply afresh" always permits an immediate second application.
In M/s Faime Makers Pvt. Ltd. v. District Deputy Registrar, 2025 INSC 423, the Supreme Court held that the society could reapply only after the legal complications identified in the first rejection order were resolved before the appropriate court. The society had not challenged that order or resolved those issues, so the competent authority could not grant relief on a second application. A society that disputes a final rejection should challenge it rather than file a fresh application to get round it.
If the order expressly allows refiling once a specified defect is cured, the society may be able to reapply after complying with that condition. The exact wording of the order, and whether it decided an issue finally, matter.
Stamp duty is a separate matter
A dispute about the stamp duty assessed on the deed is not a challenge to the deemed conveyance order. The Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958 has its own appeal provisions against the Collector's orders, with their own time limits and forums. See the guide to charges and stamp duty.
Common questions
Is there an appeal against a deemed conveyance order?
A party challenging the order may approach the Bombay High Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, but the Court's role is narrow: the Supreme Court says it should generally interfere with an order granting deemed conveyance only if the order is manifestly illegal (Arunkumar H. Shah HUF, 2025 INSC 524).
Can the builder stop registration by filing a petition?
Filing a petition alone does not restrain registration. The builder has to obtain a court order prohibiting registration or execution. The Supreme Court has said that a registering officer cannot sit in appeal over the competent authority's order, but may withhold registration where a competent court's prohibitory order is in force (Arunkumar H. Shah HUF).
Can a society challenge a rejection of its application?
Yes. A society may challenge a rejection by writ petition. Whether it can instead reapply depends on the terms and finality of the order: it may be possible to correct a defect where the order allows that, but a fresh application cannot be used to reopen a final determination or avoid conditions in the rejection order (M/s Faime Makers, 2025 INSC 423).
This article is general information about the law in Maharashtra as of November 2026. It is not legal advice, and the right course in any case depends on its facts.