In short: Section 284 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 allows a caveat against probate or administration. In the Bombay High Court, once the caveat is supported by an affidavit the petition becomes a testamentary suit, in which the right to the grant is decided.
What a caveat is
Section 284 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 says caveats against the grant of probate or administration may be lodged with a District Judge or a District Delegate, in the form given in Schedule V as nearly as circumstances admit. In the Bombay High Court, testamentary matters are governed by Chapter XXVI of the Original Side Rules, and Rule 401 provides for filing caveats in petitions for probate.
Who can lodge one, and by when
The Bombay High Court has dismissed a caveat where the caveator was not next of kin and showed no substantial interest in the estate. It has also held that a caveat filed after the order directing issuance of probate is not maintainable, and that the remedy then is a petition for revocation.
What happens after a caveat
- Citations call upon persons claiming an interest in the estate to come and see the proceedings (section 283).
- The caveator files an affidavit in support of the caveat within the time fixed by Rule 402 of the Original Side Rules.
- Once the caveat is supported by the affidavit and accepted, the petition is treated as a contentious matter and becomes a testamentary suit (Rule 403).
- Under section 295, where there is contention the proceedings take, as nearly as may be, the form of a regular suit.
After a grant
If a grant has already been made, a person who objects may apply for its revocation under section 263. The High Court has said the circumstances listed in the explanations to section 263 are not exhaustive.
A common misunderstanding
The belief I meet most often is that once a caveat is filed, the caveator is protected. It is not that kind of safeguard. A caveat is a notice: its effect is that a copy of the petition or suit is served on the caveator if the other side files a proceeding. It does not stop the other side from filing. The caveat also has to be served on the other side, and in a probate petition it must be supported by an affidavit, because without that affidavit the petition does not turn into a testamentary suit.
Quick answers
Can anyone lodge a caveat?
The Bombay High Court has dismissed a caveat where the caveator was not next of kin and showed no substantial interest in the estate.
Can a caveat be filed after the court has ordered probate?
The Bombay High Court has held that a caveat filed after the order directing issuance of probate is not maintainable. The remedy then is a petition for revocation.
Sources
- Indian Succession Act, 1925, section 284 (Indian Kanoon)
- Bombay High Court: caveat makes the proceedings contentious (Indian Kanoon)
- Bombay High Court: Original Side Rules 399, 401 to 403 (Indian Kanoon)
- Bombay High Court: caveat after probate order (LawText summary)
- Bombay High Court: caveator without interest (LawText summary)
- Bombay High Court: section 263 explanations not exhaustive (LiveLaw)
General information only. This article describes the law in Maharashtra as of November 2026. It is not legal advice, and the right course in any case depends on its facts.